News 
 Opinion 
 Editorial 
 General 
 Drug taking is not acceptable, even when in prison 

Drug taking is not acceptable, even when in prison

9/07/2008 10:35:00 AM
Nobody has asked me to give any advice about Canberra's new prison, the Alexander Maconochie Centre, but there has already been fairly extensive discussion in the columns of this newspaper and in many public meetings, suggesting the prison should provide a needle-exchange program for those prisoners who are addicted to drugs, and I feel obliged to offer an alternative view.

I understand the ACT Government has decided not to make a final decision on this matter until the prison has been operating for some 12 to 18 months, understandable as a decision either way is bound to be controversial and may be seen as breaching human rights and even putting lives at risk.

Of the 80 or so prisons in Australia, it is relevant that not one has incorporated a needle-exchange program. It is commendable for Canberra to be in the forefront of progress and reform in the management of convicted offenders, but I am not sure we should be the first in this area.

Those supporting needle exchange argue syringes are exchanged in hazardous ways by the prisoners in most, if not all, Australian prisons. If we want to reduce the harm of spreading blood-borne diseases (especially HIV and hepatitis C) then it is better to provide clean needles, or at least provide bleach which the prisoners could use to clean their own syringes. (This may reduce the risk of HIV transmission but not of hepatitis C.) While I am a reluctant supporter of needle-exchange programs in the outside community, I am not, at this time, convinced such programs in prisons are either necessary or desirable.

There are many things being done, or could be done, to keep illicit drugs out of prisons. I have no doubt this will also be the case in the Alexander Maconochie Centre. In summary, these activities include:

Random searching of all persons entering the prison, including staff, visitors and prisoners.

Periodic searching for drugs, perhaps with the assistance of trained dogs, of all prison areas.

Urine testing of prisoners, both on a random basis, to establish base levels, and on a targeted basis.

The provision of methadone to prisoners who are classified by a medical officer as addicts.

Providing for non-contact visits between prisoners and their visitors where an attempt to smuggle drugs into the prison has been proven.

Providing pocketless clothing for prisoners during visits where smuggling has been suspected.

Searching all prisoners after visits.

Providing intensive drug treatment programs for prisoners who volunteer to participate.

Providing education and public-awareness programs on the dangers and consequences of illicit drug use and trafficking.

That is already a fairly long list, but that is not all. I understand that our new prison will also use low-level X-ray surveillance equipment, not unlike that used in airports, to scan all people entering the facility. This will detect all metal objects, even if hidden in body cavities, including the metal needle of a plastic syringe. This equipment will make it unnecessary to impose the indignity of strip-searching on suspected traffickers.

With such an array of procedures and equipment all aiming to keep drugs out of prison, it would seem to me to be illogical in the extreme for the correctional authorities to provide syringes to make the injection of drugs safer for the users. If we do that, why don't we also provide the actual drugs to ensure that they too are quite safe?

I am not suggesting that genuine addicts should be left to come off drugs without assistance and support. Cold turkey detoxification is a thing of the past, now medical staff are able to predict the sequence of unpleasant symptoms likely to be suffered by addicts when they are deprived of drugs. Initially, there will be extreme agitation and stress that can be treated with sedatives. Then there will probably be acute headaches, followed by nausea, which can each be treated as they occur.

After that, intensive counselling, together with dietary advice and a program of vigorous physical activity will almost certainly be needed, and if all of that fails there is always the option of methadone.

The fact that the battle against addiction can be won is illustrated by the dramatic reduction in the prevalence of smoking throughout Australia over the past two or more decades. I am reliably informed nicotine addiction is much more difficult to break than addiction to heroin, cocaine or other drugs.

Probably the most important weapon available in the establishment and maintenance of a drug-free prison in Canberra is the newly trained and enthusiastic staff of custodial officers, most of whom have not become cynical and defeatist by working in other prison systems. Good custodial officers get to know the prisoners in their care and should be able to see the signs of drug taking if it occurs. They can then report their suspicions to senior staff for appropriate action. Their union is apparently opposed to needle exchange in prisons, but the justification for this opposition seems to me to be more selfish than altruistic.

The custodial officers will be supported by a range of professional staff, including doctors and nurses, welfare officers, industry supervisors, education and therapeutic program officers, all of whom will be motivated to reduce the probability of reoffending of our prisoners in order to make a positive contribution to the safety and wellbeing of the broader community. That will not be achieved if the message is given that drug taking is normal and acceptable behaviour, even in prison.

David Biles is a consultant criminologist and professorial associate in corrections at Charles Sturt University.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

20/11/2008 | There is something worse than having one GFC. That's having two.
Yourguide to Your Toyota
Click here NOW to take the AIC survey
 
For the latest in sport - click here
 
Babies of 2008 - click here to find out more
 
Classifieds
 
CT Home Delivery
 
Photo Sales - click here
 
Domain.com.au
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...